# 6 Drug Driving Cases That Were Dropped — And Why

> Source: https://drugdrivingsolicitors.co.uk/6-drug-driving-cases-that-were-dropped-and-why/
> Last updated: 2026-10-28
> Author: gareth
> Six drug driving cases that collapsed before trial, from roadside test failures to lab and disclosure errors, and what each one shows.

A positive roadside swab or a lab result “over the limit” can feel like the case is already decided. It isn’t. Drug driving prosecutions rest on a chain of forensic and procedural steps — the roadside test, the blood draw, the lab analysis, the disclosure of that evidence to the defence — and if any link in that chain fails, the case can collapse before it ever reaches a verdict.

Kenway Miller Solicitors has represented clients in dozens of drug driving cases that ended in discontinuance, dismissal, or acquittal. Here are six real examples from the firm’s own case history, and the specific reason each one fell apart.

## 1\. The Lab Lost Its Accreditation Mid-Case — R v LT, Llandudno Magistrates’ Court (March 2021)

Several of the firm’s cases turned on the same discovery: that the laboratory which analysed the blood sample had lost its UKAS accreditation to perform the specific tests required under section 5A of the Road Traffic Act 1988. In Mr T’s case, this only came to light after the prosecution’s own analytical data pack was served and reviewed. Once the loss of accreditation was established, the reliability of the entire analysis was in doubt. When the prosecution asked for an adjournment on the day of trial, the court refused, and no evidence was offered.

**Why it matters:** an “above the limit” result is only as good as the lab that produced it. If that lab wasn’t properly accredited to do the test, the number on the report may not stand up in court at all.

## 2\. The Prosecution Missed Its Own Disclosure Deadlines — Mr Sharpe \[Case Discontinued, October 2018\]

Mr Sharpe entered a not guilty plea and the court set a clear timetable for the prosecution to disclose its forensic report and the underlying material. The deadline came and went. A further hearing produced fresh directions — which were also missed. By the time the case reached a preliminary hearing just weeks before trial, the prosecution still hadn’t complied, and discontinued the case rather than proceed without the evidence in order.

**Why it matters:** the Criminal Procedure Rules place real obligations on the prosecution to disclose its evidence on time. Persistent failure to do so isn’t a technicality — courts have repeatedly refused to let the prosecution rely on evidence disclosed too late, which can be fatal to their case.

## 3\. There Wasn’t Enough Blood to Test — R v CH, Bexley Magistrates’ Court \[Case Discontinued, November 2020\]

Mr H sent part of his own blood specimen to an independent forensic toxicologist. That expert’s conclusion was straightforward: there simply wasn’t enough blood in the sample to carry out a valid analysis. Once this was put to the Crown Prosecution Service, along with a formal defence statement, the case was discontinued about a week before trial.

**Why it matters:** the volume, handling, and division of a blood sample are all governed by strict rules. Independent testing of your own portion of the sample can uncover problems the prosecution’s lab never flagged.

## 4\. A Genuine Medical Reason Was Never Properly Assessed — R v Franklin, Cambridge Magistrates’ Court \[Case Discontinued, April 2022\]

Mr Franklin was charged with failing to provide a specimen after telling police he had a needle phobia. Under the law, once someone raises a possible medical reason for not giving a sample, a medical professional is supposed to assess whether it amounts to a reasonable excuse — but in his case, no medical professional was ever called in to make that assessment. An expert report, drawing on his medical records and a consultation with him, confirmed the phobia was genuine. Faced with that evidence, and its own procedural failure, the prosecution dropped the case before trial.

**Why it matters:** “failure to provide” isn’t automatically an offence. If you have a genuine medical reason, the police are required to get that properly assessed — and if they don’t, it can undermine their whole case.

## 5\. The Result Was Actually Under the Limit — R v Singh, Swindon Magistrates’ Court \[Case Discontinued, December 2022\]

In an unusual case, Mr Singh’s blood specimen came back below the legal limit — yet he was still charged, this time with the separate offence of driving while unfit through drugs, based partly on things he’d said in a police interview months later. Professor Atholl Johnston, instructed as an expert, concluded the level found in his blood was inconsistent with what he’d described taking, and unlikely to have had much effect on him at all. Combined with a separate error in the hospital’s paperwork, the prosecution ultimately discontinued the case.

**Why it matters:** being charged doesn’t mean the evidence actually supports it. A below-limit result, or expert scrutiny of what a level would realistically mean for someone’s ability to drive, can undo a charge built on shakier ground than it first appears.

## 6\. The Officer’s Own Evidence Didn’t Hold Up — R v Lewis, Manchester Magistrates’ Court \[Case Dismissed, February 2023\]

The arresting officer’s witness statement in Mr Lewis’s case described the roadside drug test showing a “blue line” for cocaine — but that’s not how a positive result actually displays on that device; a genuine positive shows two red lines. The officer’s account also contradicted itself elsewhere about which drug the test was supposedly positive for. When cross-examined at trial, these inconsistencies were exposed, and the prosecution accepted it could no longer prove the roadside test had been positive at all — which undermined the legal basis for demanding a blood sample in the first place. No further evidence was offered.

**Why it matters:** roadside test results and the officers who record them can be challenged like any other evidence. Inconsistencies in how an officer describes the test — even seemingly small ones — can be enough to unravel the case.

## The Common Thread

None of these six cases were dropped because the police “changed their mind.” Each one turned on something specific and provable: an unaccredited lab, a missed disclosure deadline, an insufficient sample, an unassessed medical reason, a result that didn’t match the charge, or evidence that didn’t stand up to scrutiny. In every case, it took a defence team that knew exactly where to look.

If you’re facing a drug driving charge, the details of your stop, your sample, and the evidence behind the charge may matter far more than a single number on a lab report. Speaking to a specialist solicitor early gives you the best chance of finding out whether one of these issues applies to your case too.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts.

---
Kenway Miller Solicitors Ltd, Carlton Place, 28-32 Greenwood St, Altrincham, WA14 1RZ. Call 0800 4334 678. Regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Company number 7497109.
